What's a Bear Put Spread? |
By Price Headley |
Published
07/11/2007
|
Options
|
Unrated
|
|
What's a Bear Put Spread?
A bear put spread is basically an upside down bull call spread. The key difference, of course, is you're expecting a stock to move downward. You not expecting the stock to be just neutral or bearish. You want the stock to go lower. As usual, an example will clarify the concept.
Say you think Disney (DIS) is finally going lower, and you want to get a little more leverage on the downtrend than just shorting the stock would provide. With the current price at $34.52, you could just buy an in-the-money put option -- perhaps the August 35.00 puts, at a price of $1.45 (or $145 per contract). If the stock fell all the way to $32.50, your puts would be intrinsically worth about $2.50, or $250 per contract (plus a little more, for time value). At that point, the $2.02 price decline in shares of DIS would mean about a 72% gain ($250 exit price less the $145 entry price = 72% gain).
Not bad, right? But, your total percentage return could be even better. To lower your overall cost basis, and make the trade a bear put spread, you could short an out-of-the-money put with the same expiration month. In this case, probably the $32.50 puts make the most sense (we'll see why in a second). You could sell/short these $32.50 puts for 35 cents, or $35 per contract. Thus, your net expense to take the entire trade would just be $110 per contract ($145 to buy the 35 puts, less the $35 in proceeds you get from selling the 32.50 puts). Disney's move from $34.52 would then mean a total trade gain of 127%, much better than the 72% gain on just the purchase of the 35 puts. Why? Your value on the 35 puts is still $250, but your net cost basis is now only $110.
But, and there's always one of these, that's also going to be the maximum gain here. If DIS falls to anything under $32.50, the puts you shorted are going to be exercised against you, which you could offset by exercising the 35 puts you own. The net difference between those two is your maximum gain -- $2.50, or $250 per contract. Conversely, just owning the 35 put without shorting the 32.50 put could theoretically mean near infinite gains.
So why bother? Like we said last time, this isn't meant to be a home-run hitting strategy. Bear put spreads, like bull call spreads, have a primary intent to lower your cost basis. You still have to be right abut your directional call though.
Still doesn't seem worth it? Here's the attraction. Like we said with the bull call spread, it's not easy to feel like you're capping your gains. But, be honest, what are the odds DIS is really going to fall under 32.50 over the next seven weeks? It's certainly possible, but is it likely? If you think it is, then yes, you're correct, the bear put spread isn't worth it. But, if you think a 5.7% decline in a blue-chip isn't likely between now and mid-August, then the bear put spread is a way of getting a little more bang for your buck without necessarily giving up much (if anything).
Nuances: In general, it's best to buy a put that's barely in the money, and it's best to short a put that's not too far out of the money. Otherwise, it's really not mathematically worth it. When there's a $5 separation between strikes, this can be hard to do (or when the current stock price is at inconvenient levels between strikes). For that reason, you may find a little more flexibility using stocks with strike intervals of only $2.50.
Price Headley is the founder and chief analyst of BigTrends.com.
|